Before we go any further, let’s get one thing straight: this isn’t an original idea. It’s been done a few times. Even Hollywood has managed to re-package the idea of reanimating dead-exes for main-stream audiences, like when a recently decreased Eva Longoria harassed Lake Bell for an hour and a half in Over Her Dead Body (don’t bother). And who can forget Death Becomes Her? But it’s never been done as well as this.
Ex-girlfriends are creepy enough without being dead. But if you’re going to run with the metaphor of the end of a relationship being death, make the ex properly dead. Make them look like the Corpse Bride as in Nina Forever. Over-emphasise the weirdness of the physical presence of exes by having them take part in an awkward threesome with their ex-partner and said partner’s new boo, as they do in Nina Forever. Highlight the pain of finding the old flame’s stuff by having them appear and smear blood everywhere, as they do in Nina Forever. And make it sexy as hell, as they do in Nina Forever.
Just do it like Nina Forever, O.K.?
However, while the film is riddled with black humour, it doesn’t feel like it’s all that funny. It’s actually pretty serious. The performances are so straight you could use them to plot graphs. While the situation has the potential to be hilarious, many of the opportunities for witty one-liners have been passed up on. But maybe that’s what stops this from being Over Her Dead Body.